Why Ethics Can't Save Tech
Summary
As fake news floods our feeds and small businesses suffer due to disruption from startups, many tech designers are hearing exhortations to focus on ethics. There are tool kits, checklists and even a sort of hippocratic oath for designers to take. These efforts are laudable and understandable, and they can help in some ways -- notably, in reducing harms of bias. But ethics also have limits because private sector capitalism is a force that is much bigger than anything that any one person can do. Instead, a countervailing force, such as the public sector, is needed to shape our technology. How might designers better understand, and even seek to work with and strengthen the public sector -- whose role it is to shape society? Alexandra is the author of the new Rosenfeld Media title, Deliberate Intervention: Using Policy and Design to Blunt the Harms of New Technology
Key Insights
-
•
Ethical design can address some tech pain points but often fails to prevent systemic harms that occur beyond individual user experiences.
-
•
Systemic harms often emerge after technology deployment and are difficult to detect through standard UX research focused on pain points.
-
•
Many harms in technology contradict core business models, making them controversial and hard to fix through design alone.
-
•
Policy, driven by collective values, complements UX design’s focus on profit and user delight and is essential to mitigate societal harms.
-
•
Designers who understand both user problems and policy landscapes can more effectively advocate for harm reduction through legislation and regulation.
-
•
Cross-sector collaboration between design and policy is still nascent but shows promising examples like regulatory sandboxes in fintech.
-
•
User-centered design methods can and should be incorporated into various stages of the policy cycle to improve policymaking.
-
•
International contexts reveal different relationships between UX, capitalism, and public sector involvement, highlighting the uniqueness of the US tech ecosystem.
-
•
Civil society and consumer voices play a critical role in influencing design and technology policy, often pushing for accessibility and ethical considerations.
-
•
Designers should abandon the savior complex and recognize their influence has limits, encouraging collaborative systemic approaches.
Notable Quotes
"Design ethics can impact some harms of new technology but not all."
"Standard design research looks for pain points, not harms, and harms often cannot be identified in typical user research."
"Many tech harms run counter to business goals and can be controversial to address."
"Policy is ideally driven by values, while UX in the private sector is driven by delight and profit."
"How do we as designers connect more deeply with the policy world? That’s still a developing thing."
"Technology moves faster than policymaking — that’s the pacing problem we need to address."
"User-centered design methods can be used at every stage of policy making, from intention setting to evaluation."
"We should reconsider the savior complex designers sometimes have — we’re not all powerful."
"The future of our technology cannot and should not rest solely on the ethics of individual designers."
"I’m totally freaked out by facial recognition and wonder why we don’t get together as consumers to push back on bad designs."
Or choose a question:
More Videos
"If you don’t test, you’re relying on opinion, which can drastically degrade the customer experience."
Erin WeigelReal-world lessons to improve your conversion rates
June 26, 2024
"When you ask a question, try to ask one at a time so the model doesn't get lost."
Daniel KorczynskiWhy AI Is Bad at Research (and how to make it actually useful)
March 10, 2026
"We set expectations for who is owner and who is contributor in asynchronous work so decisions can move forward."
Kim LenoxLeading Distributed Global Teams
May 20, 2019
"I’m very fortunate. I have great medical care. I don’t know what’s going to happen, but I am going to live my life to the fullest."
Brendan JarvisFraming Tomorrow by Questioning Today
June 8, 2022
"Being present in meetings not led by design and listening can be more powerful than leading every conversation."
Carol MassaDesigning Health: Integrating Service Design, Technology, and Strategy to Transform Patient and Clinician Experiences
December 3, 2024
"There was a lot of communication needed around roles, especially since our software developer was external and not always involved in day-to-day decisions."
Dr Chloe SharpUsing Evidence and Collaboration for Setting and Defending Priorities
November 29, 2023
"We are the problem we’re trying to replace — some legacy digital systems we created 20 years ago are still running."
Sarah Auslander Betsy Ramaccia Gordon RossInsights Panel
November 18, 2022
"His sigh was just a sigh. It was not a signal of any defect or usability issue to solve."
Susan Simon-DanielsWar Stories LIVE! Susan Simon-Daniels
March 30, 2020
"Tools are evolving fast; it's crucial to analyze which tools will remain market leaders before heavy integration."
Farid SabitovAutomatization for Large Enterprise Teams
January 8, 2024
Latest Books All books
Dig deeper with the Rosenbot
What are practical steps for introducing joyful design within efficiency-driven teams?
What strategies help speed up the procurement and legal review of UX research platforms in organizations like LinkedIn?
What are best practices for engaging C-suite executives and physicians as champions for B2B healthcare apps?