Rosenverse

This video is only accessible to Gold members. Log in or register for a free Gold Trial Account to watch.

Log in Register

Most conference talks are accessible to Gold members, while community videos are generally available to all logged-in members.

Why Ethics Can't Save Tech
Gold
Friday, November 18, 2022 • Civic Design 2022
Share the love for this talk
Why Ethics Can't Save Tech
Speakers: Alexandra Schmidt
Link:

Summary

As fake news floods our feeds and small businesses suffer due to disruption from startups, many tech designers are hearing exhortations to focus on ethics. There are tool kits, checklists and even a sort of hippocratic oath for designers to take. These efforts are laudable and understandable, and they can help in some ways -- notably, in reducing harms of bias. But ethics also have limits because private sector capitalism is a force that is much bigger than anything that any one person can do. Instead, a countervailing force, such as the public sector, is needed to shape our technology. How might designers better understand, and even seek to work with and strengthen the public sector -- whose role it is to shape society? Alexandra is the author of the new Rosenfeld Media title, Deliberate Intervention: Using Policy and Design to Blunt the Harms of New Technology

Key Insights

  • Not all harms caused by technology can be identified or solved through standard design research focused on pain points.

  • Harms can be invisible to individual users and often emerge at societal levels over time, like Amazon’s impact on local businesses.

  • Addressing technology harms often conflicts with corporate business models prioritizing profit and user engagement.

  • Policy and design cycles share similar iterative structures but differ fundamentally in drivers: values versus profit.

  • Designers have a unique vantage point to influence policy by bringing user-centric insights to lawmakers and regulators.

  • Regulatory sandboxes in sectors like fintech offer a promising model for collaborative policy and design experimentation.

  • Ethics tools in design can curb certain harms, such as bias and online abuse, but cannot address systemic or structural issues alone.

  • Civil society plays a critical role in shaping public spaces and technology design, yet is often underrepresented in tech ethics discussions.

  • International contexts, such as Sweden’s integration of UX in the public sector, differ greatly from the US, where UX is often tied to capitalism.

  • Focusing on specific harms rather than attempting to address all ethical issues simultaneously enables more actionable and impactful work.

Notable Quotes

"Design ethics can impact some harms of new technology but not all and that’s why ethics can’t save tech."

"Standard design research looks for pain points, not harms, and harms often cannot be identified in user research."

"Harms often accrue to the level of society rather than individuals and only emerge over time."

"Policy is ideally driven by values; UX in the private sector is driven by delight and profit."

"Our influence and power as designers have limits; the future of technology cannot rest solely on individual ethics."

"You can connect with policymakers, like the FTC chair encouraging designers to combat dark patterns."

"Regulatory sandboxes allow for experimentation with policy in a sandbox environment and are worth exploring further."

"Civil society has pushed for public spaces to work for all, showing the power of collective voices in design."

"In Sweden, UX is more integrated into the public sector and not equated with capitalism as it is in the US."

"Focus on one specific harm rather than trying to address all at once; this creates communities of practice and shared progress."

Ask the Rosenbot
Brigette Metzler
Research Repositories: A global project by the ResearchOps Community (Videoconference)
2020 • Advancing Research Community
Michelle Bejian Lotia
Rolling Out a Repository: How Zapier Centralizes Insights from Across their Organization
2023 • Advancing Research 2023
Gold
Erin Weigel
Get Your Whole Team Testing to Design for Impact
2024 • Rosenfeld Community
Renee Reid
Becoming a ResearchH.E.R (Highly Enterprise Ready)
2019 • Enterprise Experience 2019
Gold
Ross Smith
Breaking Barriers with Empathy
2017 • Enterprise Experience 2017
Gold
Laine Riley Prokay
How DesignOps can Drive Inclusive Career Ladders for All
2021 • DesignOps Summit 2021
Gold
Mohammad Hossein Jarrahi
Contextuality problem: Exploring the Benefits of Qualitative and Quantitative Research
2023 • QuantQual Interest Group (Rosenfeld Community)
Ash Brown
Silver Linings: What DesignOps Learned in the Shift to WFH
2020 • DesignOps Summit 2020
Gold
Peter Boersma
How to Define and Maintain a DesignOps Roadmap
2023 • DesignOps Summit 2023
Gold
Marc Rettig
Discussion
2015 • Enterprise UX 2015
Gold
Research Operations at Scale
2017 • DesignOps Summit 2017
Gold
Alan Williams
Designing essential financial services for those in need (Videoconference)
2022 • Civic Design Community
Jonathon Colman
How to Maximize the Impact of Content Design
2024 • DesignOps Summit 2020
Gold
Group Activity: Making Sense of DesignOps
2017 • DesignOps Summit 2017
Gold
Amelia Cole
Data-Prompted Interviews
2021 • QuantQual Interest Group (Rosenfeld Community)
Lija Hogan
Three Years Out: Perspectives on the Near-Term Future of User Research (Videoconference)
2024 • Advancing Research Community

More Videos

"Teaching product managers heuristics took 15 minutes, and now they use that shared language to articulate design."

Standardizing Product Merits for Leaders, Designers, and Everyone

June 15, 2018

Simon Wardley

"Space has meaning in a map—if you move components around without reason, it’s no longer a map."

Simon Wardley

Maps and Topographical Intelligence (Videoconference)

January 31, 2019

Sandra Camacho

"Bias is a tendency, feeling or opinion for or against something without reason or evidence."

Sandra Camacho

Creating More Bias-Proof Designs

January 22, 2025

Darian Davis

"Reviewing decision points creates a source of truth and makes it harder to forget or scrap earlier agreements."

Darian Davis

Lessons from a Toxic Work Relationship

January 8, 2024

Fisayo Osilaja

"My goal today is to showcase how generative AI can go beyond just speeding up our processes and actually catapult us in our career."

Fisayo Osilaja

[Demo] The AI edge: From researcher to strategist

June 4, 2024

Uday Gajendar

"There is a common thread in craft: dignity, purpose, utility, and beauty."

Uday Gajendar

The Wicked Craft of Enterprise UX

May 13, 2015

Davis Neable

"There is no design team responsible for the overarching experience across the entire company."

Davis Neable Guy Segal

How to Drive a Design Project When you Don’t Have a Design Team

June 10, 2021

Eniola Oluwole

"Launching a design system is not a sprint, there’s no end, it’s always a continuous process."

Eniola Oluwole

Lessons From the DesignOps Journey of the World's Largest Travel Site

October 24, 2019

Aurobinda Pradhan

"Product managers feel design is a black box; they want visibility, transparency, and accountability on timelines."

Aurobinda Pradhan Shashank Deshpande

Introduction to Collaborative DesignOps using Cubyts

September 9, 2022