Summary
Traditional design metrics and KPIs are often geared towards measuring product success. Dark metrics challenge this paradigm by proactively measuring the unintended yet harmful psychological, social, and physical effects of our technologies. The examples within digital health are plentiful. From accelerating burnout among clinicians to widening racial disparities in quality of care, we can only reach the height of our most courageous solutions when we expose our deepest failures.
Key Insights
-
•
Traditional product metrics often ignore the broader individual and societal impacts of digital health technologies.
-
•
Dark Metrics is a framework focusing on measuring disempowerment, exclusion, addiction, and distraction caused by health tech.
-
•
Disempowerment occurs when technology undermines user autonomy, especially in sensitive healthcare decision-making.
-
•
Racial bias in AI can manifest indirectly, as in algorithms using proxies like healthcare costs that perpetuate inequities.
-
•
Co-creating design solutions with diverse voices is critical to proactively identifying unintended consequences.
-
•
Measuring unhealthy engagement requires going beyond 'engagement' metrics to include wellbeing indicators like stress or eye strain.
-
•
Distraction from clinical tools (e.g., EMRs) can reduce quality of care by pulling medical professionals away from patient interaction.
-
•
Embedding racial equity rubrics into the design process helps ensure inclusive user experiences beyond just product visuals.
-
•
Augmented intelligence should support, not replace, human decision-making especially in healthcare.
-
•
Early, collaborative risk ideation exercises like 'premortems' are recommended to anticipate potential harms before launch.
Notable Quotes
"Traditional product metrics focus narrowly on the product itself, missing what success means for the people using our technologies."
"Our tools are meant to support and enhance, not to take over — we call this augmented intelligence at IBM Watson."
"An algorithm that doesn’t explicitly use race but uses healthcare costs as a proxy can perpetuate racial discrimination."
"Exclusion doesn’t have to be explicit — you just have to be indifferent to it."
"The difference between technology and slavery is that slaves are fully aware they are not free."
"Doctors don’t want to be on a machine all day; they want to help people."
"Designing for people means acknowledging where we might be exclusionary and embedding equity like accessibility."
"If the product doesn’t allow people to override decisions or control their data, it’s likely disempowering."
"Collaborative conversations and diverse co-creation help catch blind spots and biases in design."
"We have to ask before building something new: what could possibly go wrong?"
Or choose a question:
More Videos
"I think there isn’t one linear path and sometimes you face career stumbles but you need to get back up and find momentum."
Catt Small Micah Bennett Brian Carr Jessica HarlleeWhat's Next for ICs: Exploring Staff and Principal Designer Roles (Videoconference)
February 22, 2024
"Employees were graded on note quality, and their scores declined by about 10% after using the AI tool, impacting morale."
Jennifer Kong[Case study] Journeying toward AI-assisted documentation in healthcare
June 5, 2024
"Storytelling leads to better understanding and recall of key points at a later date."
Sara LogelYour Colleagues are Your Users Too
March 29, 2023
"Our UX research team leveraged detailed analyses to create Zendesk’s first set of role-based profiles as a foundation for user personas."
Veevi RosensteinBuilding for Scale: Creating the Zendesk UX Research Practice
January 8, 2024
"Once we put all these insights into the repository, things we already have get so much more value."
Michelle Bejian Lotia Anne-Marie MorellRolling Out a Repository: How Zapier Centralizes Insights from Across their Organization
March 28, 2023
"Labeling someone difficult is dangerous; challenge your feelings, the facts, and your interpretations first."
Tutti TaygerlyVideconference: How to Work with Difficult People with Tutti Taygerly
June 25, 2020
"We automated our staffing records and updated our staffing score weekly, watching it grow from 44 to nearly 80."
Patrick CommarfordDesign Staffing for Impact
January 8, 2024
"How might we humanize how and what we measure and recognize as impact?"
Frances YllanaTheme 2 Intro
September 24, 2024
"The eye is an extension of the brain; processing visuals fires new neurons and helps you think differently."
Mujtaba HameedFrameworks for Excellence: Using Visual Thinking and Communication to Elevate Your Research
March 26, 2024