Summary
Under biometric privacy laws like BIPA and CCPA, user research recordings containing users’ faces or voices can put your company at risk for lawsuits and fines. Legal departments are increasingly requiring more stringent redaction, and in some cases banning recording outright. This comes at a high cost for UX teams who are already being asked to do more with less, as losing access to recordings can increase duplicative research effort and reduce the accuracy of results. AI offers new solutions for UX teams who want to keep research recordings longer without violating biometric privacy laws. In this demo, we’ll show how we used off-the-shelf tools to intelligently redact users’ voices, faces, and bodies in research videos. By removing biometric identifiers, you can compliantly archive research recordings indefinitely, enabling your team to mine them for insights for years to come.
Key Insights
-
•
Biometric privacy laws increasingly restrict storing videos with real user faces and voices, creating risks for traditional UX research recordings.
-
•
Replacing users in research videos with AI-generated avatars preserves rich contextual information without violating privacy rules.
-
•
Tools like 11 Labs can synthesize user voices, and Wonder Studio can replace entire user bodies in videos using AI-driven 3D avatars.
-
•
Replacing the whole body rather than just the face helps avoid future biometric identification risks from unique markers like tattoos or moles.
-
•
Current AI tools for avatar creation have technical limits such as processing time restrictions and unclear licensing for enterprise legal compliance.
-
•
Blurring or redacting faces is inadequate for privacy as it loses context and doesn't protect voice biometric data.
-
•
Synthetic avatars raise ethical questions about authenticity and the accuracy of observed user behavior in research videos.
-
•
Removing visual user identity elements risks erasing diverse perspectives or accountability from the research process.
-
•
There is an ongoing tension between legal privacy obligations and maintaining the value of user research artifacts.
-
•
Widespread adoption of AI avatar tools in UX research will require collaboration with legal teams to balance innovation, privacy, and ethics.
Notable Quotes
"If you work in UX, user recordings are arguably your most valuable asset."
"Recording user research is becoming riskier due to growing biometric privacy laws in the US and Europe."
"Replacing entire bodies with avatars sidesteps concerns about unique identifiers like tattoos or moles."
"DeepFakes can look too realistic, so for legal reasons we want it clear at a glance this is not a real person."
"Blurring the entire frame loses a lot of information and still doesn’t do anything about the voice."
"Wonder Studio uses AI to segment an actor, understand their movements, and map those to a 3D model automatically."
"These tools give UX teams options to address legal concerns without sacrificing their most valuable design asset."
"How do we know what’s real if you can’t see a human in a video? Could the whole conversation be fabricated?"
"Removing visual aspects of identity can make it easier to exclude certain groups from our design process."
"Ultimately, what you can do with user recordings is a negotiation with your legal department’s risk tolerance."
Or choose a question:
More Videos
"Share everything, own nothing but credit everyone."
Zariah CameronReDesigning Wellbeing for Equitable Care in the Workplace
September 23, 2024
"Prioritization is not just for your own work, it’s for teams and whole organizations."
John Cutler Harry MaxPrioritization for designers and product managers (1st of 3 seminars) (Videoconference)
June 13, 2024
"Design is a way of organizing complexity or finding clarity in chaos."
Nick CochranGrowing in Enterprise Design through Making Connections
June 3, 2019
"I often lock a process against changes for one to two months unless a major issue arises."
Deanna SmithLeading Change with Confidence: Strategies for Optimizing Your Process
September 23, 2024
"We started the Digital Service as a subsidiary company of the government, not just a government unit."
Magdalena ZadaraZero Hour: How to Get Far Quickly When Starting Your Digital Service Unit Late
November 16, 2022
"We made it easier for him to say yes by making it easier to say no."
Nova Wehman-BrownWe've Never Done This Before
June 4, 2019
"We human researchers can help go way beyond proxy metrics such as button clicks and provide true validation of model accuracy."
Liwei DaiThe Heart and Brain of the AI Research
March 31, 2020
"By July 2020, more than 4,000 workers had arrived, 35 tested positive during quarantine but there were zero cases on BC farms employing temporary foreign workers."
Gordon Ross12 Months of COVID-19 Design and Digital Response with the British Columbia Government
December 8, 2021
"The doing is the same; the being is entirely different."
Tutti TaygerlyMake Space to Lead
June 12, 2021
