Why Changing Hearts & Minds Doesn’t Work When Promoting DE&I Efforts, but Checklists Do
Summary
- Define tangible core competencies that define each job and the criteria hiring and performance are measured on
- Create a Portfolio Review “Cheat Sheet” that allows a team to review a candidate with an anti-bias approach
- Review examples of performance review and correct instances of bias
Key Insights
-
•
Initial DEI efforts focused on changing hearts and minds often lead to burnout without measurable impact.
-
•
Bias in hiring decisions can manifest as unequal standards for candidates based on race and gender.
-
•
Creating a set of 12 core competencies helped objectively define key skills across multiple design roles.
-
•
Focusing on action-oriented 'I can' competencies over subjective knowledge helped reduce bias.
-
•
Hiring cheat sheets tied to competencies guide interview panels and reduce individual bias.
-
•
Performance reviews are high-risk areas for bias due to confirmation bias and the halo/horn effect.
-
•
Requiring three pieces of evidence for each feedback item reduces unsubstantiated biased comments.
-
•
Managers auditing peer feedback enables identification and mitigation of bias during reviews.
-
•
Evidence-based performance review workshops empowered teams to discuss and call out bias openly.
-
•
Scaling equity efforts requires integrating objective criteria into organizational processes, not just discussions.
Notable Quotes
"We were literally doing the most and having no impact."
"When we focused on objective measurements, it really highlighted the inequity and moving the goalpost based on who it was applying."
"Scale is about doing less while having greater impact."
"We wanted to move from I know, which is subjective, to I can, which can be demonstrated."
"If a candidate meets the three non-negotiables, it’s a reason to move them forward no matter what."
"Performance reviews are petri dishes for bias, especially confirmation bias and halo/horn effects."
"Give three pieces of evidence for every piece of feedback you provide an individual."
"Managers need to audit the feedback their team receives, not just accept it at face value."
"We asked people to judge others’ feedback with an anti-bias lens instead of focusing on their own biases."
"Let the bird fly of hearts and minds. Don’t go chasing waterfalls; disrupt your organization with checklists."
Or choose a question:
More Videos
"Ownership of VOC is a hot potato, so we built a coalition with a facilitator to keep it collaborative and effective."
Shipra KayanHow we Built a VoC (Voice of the Customer) Practice at Upwork from the Ground Up
September 30, 2021
"Changing culture is hard because we’re willing to change actions but resistant to changing beliefs."
Peter MorvilleThe Architecture of Understanding
May 13, 2015
"I want people to question why I’m not in the room if I’m not there."
Renee ReidBecoming a ResearchH.E.R (Highly Enterprise Ready)
June 3, 2019
"The computer metaphor of mind does not do a very good job of explaining what we see people do with their bodies."
Dane DeSutterKeeping the Body in Mind: What Gestures and Embodied Actions Tell You That Users May Not
March 26, 2024
"Involving people with disabilities from the start reveals impact and usability issues that automated testing simply cannot catch."
Sam ProulxOnline Shopping: Designing an Accessible Experience
October 3, 2023
"Three quarters of users who fail their mission don’t come back, risking lost revenue and market share."
Andrew Custage Michael MallettThe Digital Journey: Research on Consumer Frustration and Loyalty
March 29, 2023
"Persisting conversations in Slack instead of Zoom chat means folks can revisit and join conversations asynchronously."
Shelby SwitzerMaking Space for Community Knowledge-sharing in a Distributed World
December 10, 2021
"Prompting is a specialized skill, just like statistics or in-depth interviewing; the wrong wording can bias your results."
Llewyn PaineCoexisting with AI: A practical guide for researchers to navigate tools, ethics, and integration
March 11, 2025
"The only thing any of us can control is how quickly we learn and then act based on that learning."
Robin BeersNavigating organizational systems: Rethinking researcher’s role in driving change
March 13, 2025
