Handling Complexity: Framing a Scale of Design
Summary
Designing "at scale" assumes conceptual consensus on what the particular levels of that 'scale' actually are. In the last few years, UX professionals have specialized into UX researchers, product designers, service designers design strategists, etc. Nowadays, we're also witnessing the debut of a new term: "system designers". But do we really understand how these job titles and subthemes of UX fit within that scale of complexity in design? In this presentation, we'll introduce the basic levels of a scale of design, articulate how common UX job titles fit on the scale, and map how the work we commonly tackle in both research and design should also be informed by the scale of the problem we're addressing. We're also going to critique the (somewhat misguided) ways the current world of UX is handling the widespread growth in the complexity of our work.
Key Insights
-
•
Design complexity is best understood as a scale with multiple layers, from foundational theory to societal impact.
-
•
Traditional design scale models do not fully address the granularity required by modern design challenges.
-
•
Lower layers of design focus on artifact creation and micro-interactions, exemplified by practitioners like Aaron Draplin.
-
•
Product design is discipline-led and emphasizes precise, polished deliverables, while service design is multidisciplinary and tolerates imprecision.
-
•
Research quality decreases substantially at higher levels of the scale due to ambiguity and systemic complexity.
-
•
Designers must consider secondary users and the potential harm their designs may inflict beyond primary users.
-
•
Service design projects often span years and require broad organizational collaboration, including policy, business, and HR perspectives.
-
•
Systemic and ecosystem thinking is crucial for ethical design and to avoid commoditization of design and designers.
-
•
Organizational adoption of ecosystem-focused roles is increasing as companies recognize the need for system-level insights.
-
•
Operationalizing design at scale requires awareness of these layers, multidisciplinary teamwork, and evolving research approaches.
Notable Quotes
"While the majority of design happens in the lower half of this scale, we create gaps at the higher, systemic levels that we must address."
"Design projects in product design are led by designers, but in service design they are facilitated or co-facilitated by designers among many perspectives."
"If you see a system, you cannot unsee it — systemic awareness changes how you approach design."
"On lower layers, research spaces are limited and focused, while at higher layers, problem spaces are ambiguous and require holistic approaches."
"We tend to put the end user first, but we must also ask who we might be doing harm to beyond primary users."
"In product design, we answer questions to design; in service design, we ask the right questions to design."
"Many big companies now have roles related to ecosystem design like VP or senior managers of ecosystem."
"Service design projects often last two to three years and necessitate ongoing stakeholder collaboration."
"Focusing exclusively on design systems, sprints, and agile commoditizes design and reduces it to cookie-cutter processes."
"Being aware of the systemic lens is a big first step that changes how teams operate and design."
Or choose a question:
More Videos
"The difference between the way people talk about how things are done and how they are actually done reveals unconscious assumptions."
Carl TurnerYou Can Do This: Understand and Solve Organizational Problems to Jumpstart a Dead Project
March 28, 2023
"You earn your seat at the table by championing excellent customer experience and rallying the project team behind it."
Karen PascoeDeveloping Experience Teams and Talent in the Enterprise
June 8, 2016
"We share the inconvenience of meeting times across time zones, alternating so no one team always bears it."
Jilanna WilsonDistributed Design Operations Management
October 23, 2019
"We treat our shared tooling and design system as a product with a dedicated team maintaining reusable components and governance."
Shawna Hein Kevin HoffmanCreate a Cohesive Civic Design Practice Across Agency, Vendors, and Contracts
November 17, 2022
"I still kind of pause in my tracks when I see our corporate vision: a world without fear of cancer."
Barb SpantonDoing Work That Matters: A Look Beyond The Idealistic Notion of 'Doing Meaningful Work'
June 10, 2022
"We had no recipe, no formula, just vibes."
Briana ThomasThe Quiet Force: Uncovering Hidden Leadership in High-Impact Design Teams
September 24, 2024
"Coaches organize practices or drills to push players toward specific goals and improvement."
Gina MendoliaTherapists, Coaches, and Grandmas: Techniques for Service Design in Complex Systems
December 3, 2024
"Being fluent in multiple data languages and understanding behavioral and attitudinal data will be essential."
Lija Hogan Milan Mijatovic Sam Proulx Louis RosenfeldThree Years Out: Perspectives on the Near-Term Future of User Research
March 15, 2024
"Our design ops team was a step behind the growth of our design team, solving the wrong problems at the wrong scale."
John Calhoun Rachel PosmanTwo Sides of the DesignOps Coin: Teams Ops and Product Ops
January 8, 2024
Latest Books All books
Dig deeper with the Rosenbot
How do you reconcile the business realities with your mission-driven work in climate startups?
What are the core UX research tools essential for managing participant recruitment and study logistics in large companies?
What strategies help UX researchers gain access to healthcare workflows in overwhelmed systems?