Day 2 Panel
Summary
In this panel discussion, Cheryl Kaba, Ethan Marotz, and Meena Previ reflect on the challenges and opportunities of designing with AI. Cheryl highlights the need to think beyond narrow AI use cases, stressing long-term impacts and ethical considerations, especially in education where AI might replace teachers. Ethan points to AI shifting design roles to supervisory or editorial, raising concerns about de-skilling and labor protections, drawing parallels to recent labor strikes in creative industries. Meena emphasizes ethical AI practices, co-creation with stakeholders, and transparency, cautioning against blind acceptance of AI outputs. Together, they explore the importance of intentionality, participatory design, and power dynamics in AI systems, noting capitalism’s role in shaping AI's adoption and urging designers to critically engage in shaping AI’s future. The panel also discusses transparency in AI confidence, ethical frameworks beyond compliance, and the lifecycle of AI hype. They close with calls for conversations among coworkers about AI’s role, and critical questioning of who designs AI and for whom, advocating sustained reflection on AI's social and labor impacts.
Key Insights
-
•
AI design is currently in an experimental stage, often focused on narrow use cases rather than broad impacts.
-
•
The shift to AI often changes designers' roles from creators to supervisors, potentially leading to workforce de-skilling.
-
•
Ethical AI practices require active inclusion of marginalized groups in the design and feedback processes.
-
•
Transparency about AI confidence levels has decreased in modern chatbots, complicating trust and interpretation.
-
•
Designers must balance augmentation and automation carefully to avoid disempowerment and job losses.
-
•
Power dynamics are central to AI system design; systems should promote empowerment rather than control.
-
•
Sustainability and AI's environmental impact are often overlooked in technology discussions.
-
•
Ethical frameworks vary and should be adapted to specific communities and organizational goals rather than treated as universally equal.
-
•
Labor movements and unionization are relevant lenses to consider protections against AI-driven labor changes.
-
•
Effective AI integration requires intentional conversations and collective reflection among workplace stakeholders.
Notable Quotes
"We’re in this initial stage of tinkering, just trying to make the tech behave the way we expect it to."
"AI moves the practitioner into an editorial or supervisory role, which often signals de-skilling."
"We want AI to augment human skills like an electric bike, not replace them like a robotic vacuum cleaner."
"Who is designing these AI systems, why, and for whom? Are those most impacted even involved?"
"Designers need to have critical conversations with stakeholders about the direction and impacts of AI."
"Ethics is not just about compliance; it’s about doing the right thing holistically."
"Most people’s fears about AI are actually fears about capitalism."
"Transparency of AI’s confidence has mostly disappeared because generative AI is inherently confident by design."
"AI tools today are sandwiches in search of picnics—useful, but lacking killer applications yet."
"We need to redesign capitalism, but right now we don’t have time for that."
Or choose a question:
More Videos
"When projects are late or delayed it’s often due to organizational and cultural issues rather than conduct of the project team."
Carl TurnerYou Can Do This: Understand and Solve Organizational Problems to Jumpstart a Dead Project
March 28, 2023
"Most employees take at least 90 days to onboard and another 90 days to become productive — that’s half a year before you see impact."
Karen PascoeDeveloping Experience Teams and Talent in the Enterprise
June 8, 2016
"Continuous onboarding is like drinking water in sips throughout the day, not a gallon all at once."
Jilanna WilsonDistributed Design Operations Management
October 23, 2019
"Our digital experience group acts like hosts and planners making sure veterans sit down to a cohesive, inclusive meal, not just disparate dishes."
Shawna Hein Kevin HoffmanCreate a Cohesive Civic Design Practice Across Agency, Vendors, and Contracts
November 17, 2022
"Quick fixes rarely exist in these domains because beneath every problem are layers of complexity."
Barb SpantonDoing Work That Matters: A Look Beyond The Idealistic Notion of 'Doing Meaningful Work'
June 10, 2022
"Silent leaders are people who prefer action over words and advocate in more intimate settings."
Briana ThomasThe Quiet Force: Uncovering Hidden Leadership in High-Impact Design Teams
September 24, 2024
"Creating and holding space is like putting bumpers up in bowling so people know they won’t fail if they engage."
Gina MendoliaTherapists, Coaches, and Grandmas: Techniques for Service Design in Complex Systems
December 3, 2024
"Future UX includes designing for user discovery in conversational and augmented interfaces, not just clicks."
Lija Hogan Milan Mijatovic Sam Proulx Louis RosenfeldThree Years Out: Perspectives on the Near-Term Future of User Research
March 15, 2024
"With our new operating model, partners are more confident funding UX ops because of increased clarity and focus."
John Calhoun Rachel PosmanTwo Sides of the DesignOps Coin: Teams Ops and Product Ops
January 8, 2024
